Skip to main content

Phaedrus' Philosophology

As I was reading Robert M. Pirsig's second novel, Lila, I came across the idea of "Philosophology". Philosophology, or the study of philosophy. This idea saved my life.

One of my goals since graduating high school was to study philosophy, to get a coherent understanding of major ideas from major philosophers. I wanted to know enough to group philosophers, to concisely sum up their ideas, and to read their works in the original languages that they were written in.

I, like the people Pirsig described, thought that knowing about philosophy was essential before pursuing my own philosophy. What if people already wrote down what I wanted to write down? What if strong counterarguments already existed?

But Pirsig said the same thing that a professor from the Yonsei Philosophy Department had said to me a year ago: given our short lifespans, it would be impossible.

"You can imagine the ridiculousness of an art historian taking his students to museums, having them write a thesis on some historical or technical aspect of what they see there, and after a few years of this giving them degrees that say they are accomplished artists. They've never held a brush or a mallet and chisel in their hands. All they know is art history." I had refused to believe my professor, but somehow Phaedrus' rhetoric succeeded in clearing all doubts. I should start painting again.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Problem with Measuring Opinion

The problem with studies conducted by gathering opinions is that the measurement system is inherently flawed. Before examining the flaws, take a quick look at a sample Big Five personality test: http://personality-testing.info/printable/big-five-personality-test.pdf This test uses what social scientists call the "Likert scale". Usually, 4 or 5 choices are available, where each choice represents the feelings of the survey taker. The scale should be familiar, though its name might not be. By Nicholas Smithvectorization: Own work - Own work, based on File:Example Likert Scale.jpg Likert scales are useful for simple surveys designed to summarize the general opinion of the public. The problem starts when social scientists try to use Likert scales to conduct statistical research. Obviously, the Likert scale is limited by human irrationality. R espondents might avoid the extremes. They might respond in ways that make themselves look good. They might choose an extreme opin...

On Breaking Rules

Rules are great. They provide justice, order, and stability. But must they always be followed? If not (and one would think not), which  rules can be broken, and when? The Sufficient Conditions for Rule Breaking But what about rules that do make sense—ones that serve a good, clear purpose? When can they be broken? It is not possible to consider every possible scenario regarding each rule, so here is a "Rule for Breaking Rules": When the purpose of the rule is understood, and when breaking that rule does not go against its purpose, the rule can be broken . Here are some examples worth considering. Jaywalking The main purpose of traffic lights and other traffic laws is safety. Jaywalking is morally acceptable when a pedestrian, on an empty street, for instance, correctly judges that it is safe enough to cross. In undeveloped Chinese cities, traffic lights are ignored, so attention must be paid more to oncoming vehicles than to the traffic lights. Waiting ...

Deromanticizing Numbers

My first post (other than the introduction ):  A discussion on the obsession with seemingly relevant, yet probably meaningless numbers (like "first"). Should We Stop Celebrating New Years? Over the last few years, I tried not to take notice of New Years. I thought it was silly of us to celebrate the fact that a 4 digit integer reached its successor. I am not saying that rather than celebrating, we should instead despair the fact that we are a year closer to our deaths (though this is true). Nor am I trying to stop anyone else from celebrating. I am simply perplexed about the fact that we celebrate an event that is, upon reflection, quite ordinary. Celebration of a new year every year suggests that there is not that much to celebrate in life and too much need for celebration. This idea can be applied on other cultural phenomena, especially anything annual, like birthdays and anniversaries, but these examples are redundant. Other non-annual applications of this idea incl...