Skip to main content

Taxi Incentives

Whether they show it or not, most passengers are suspicious of taxis. This is because there is a conflict of interest: needlessly roundabout routes drive up the taxi's profits, while they cost passengers time and money. Is there a way to line up the incentives of drivers and passengers?

The solution is to pay taxis before the ride, not after. The cost would be based on the distance and the traffic situation. This pre-paid method would be better than the current after-pay method for three reasons.

First, it would be in the best interest of drivers to take the passenger to his or her destination as soon as possible so that they can quickly find a new customer.

Second, because the passenger knows this fact, there would be fewer arguments about the route the drivers take. A driver's mistake in taking a slower path could be mildly annoying for the passenger, but not irritating enough to incite major arguments. Passengers would also trust the drivers more when they claim that they know a faster route.

Third, there would be less traffic. This positive externality would arise because the fare would depend on the traffic situation (the heavier the traffic, the larger the costs in taking a taxi). When showed the higher costs, passengers would be more likely to take public transportation.

Granted, passengers are more likely to take public transportation even without the prepayment system, since they know that taking taxis during rush hours could be costly. But explicitly displaying the higher costs could deter a lot of passengers from taking taxis. And because the taxis know that it would be harder to find passengers during rush hours, they would be more inclined to take some time off, or at least stay away from congested areas of the city.

One possible benefit for drivers is that when passengers call for a taxi, they could bid up their prices. When taxis are much needed, for example, during stormy weather, passengers who have a higher willingness to pay could offer a higher price. This first degree price discrimination is beneficial to everyone, since the people who most need taxis would get them, and taxi drivers could increase profits. This is much more efficient and civilized than lining people up, or having taxis stop for people who most aggressively flag them down. Some may argue that this would not be fair for the less wealthy. In my view, taxis are a luxury good, and those who cannot afford higher costs of taxis on a rainy day always have the option of taking the subway.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A Question on Reincarnation

Does reincarnation maintain the number of organisms living in the world? Suppose there is a world where there are only three living organisms, and they are reincarnated when they die. What happens when one is about to die? If the remaining two reproduce sexually, will they forced to procreate as the third one dies, thereby maintaining the number of organisms in that world? What if two individuals die at once? Would single celled organisms naturally evolve out of protein? Perhaps the number of living organisms and souls is not strictly maintained. This would explain the exponential growth and decay of populations. But if everything is reincarnated, how would this be possible? Where would new life come from?

Deromanticizing Numbers

My first post (other than the introduction ):  A discussion on the obsession with seemingly relevant, yet probably meaningless numbers (like "first"). Should We Stop Celebrating New Years? Over the last few years, I tried not to take notice of New Years. I thought it was silly of us to celebrate the fact that a 4 digit integer reached its successor. I am not saying that rather than celebrating, we should instead despair the fact that we are a year closer to our deaths (though this is true). Nor am I trying to stop anyone else from celebrating. I am simply perplexed about the fact that we celebrate an event that is, upon reflection, quite ordinary. Celebration of a new year every year suggests that there is not that much to celebrate in life and too much need for celebration. This idea can be applied on other cultural phenomena, especially anything annual, like birthdays and anniversaries, but these examples are redundant. Other non-annual applications of this idea incl...

Behind the Facade of High SAT Scores

Most people do not care much about scores after high school, and even if the topic comes up, I have found that many top scorers (understandably) have a tendency to refrain from speaking too much on it. This is not helpful for younger students who need genuine advice. Here is my experience . My real experience, not a you can do it too  success story. When I started, I had no idea where to start. I was a sophomore in high school, and all my Asian friends were studying for the SAT in hagwons . I had never been to a hagwon . The y told me these hagwons provide information on everything about the test, such as when and where to take it, the best times to take it, the best times to prepare for it, and most importantly, how to prepare for it. Very little effort was needed to convince my parents that I wanted to enroll for the summer. Come summer vacation. I took five weeks of classes in June and July, Monday to Friday, from 7 a.m. to noon. Basically it was around 2 hours of Read...